Shelby's wife, Kelly, has taken a job at the mall as Santa's helper, but Shelby knows it's not because of the extra money she's earning or that she wants to bring joy to the little kids. Instead, Shelby knows it's because of Jared, the mall's Santa, and when Kelly doesn't return home right after work, Shelby goes to discover why. What he discovers is Santa filling Kelly's stocking, and Shelby can't look away.